Last spring, somewhere between Point Pelee and Long Point, I nearly dropped my binoculars. There, blazing in the canopy like a dropped ember, was a scarlet tanager. Or rather, the scarlet tanager. I’d seen the field guide pictures. I’d listened to the slightly hoarse robin-like song on Merlin. But none of that prepared me for the reality: that impossible red, that ink-black wing contrast, that “yes, I’m worth flying across the country for” presence. And reader, I have the photos to prove it. Okay, photo. I got one photo. But look!
These stunners—Piranga olivacea, if you want to sound clever in front of your friends—have a name that’s weirdly misleading. “Olivacea” refers not to the males, who are as olive as a fire truck, but to the females, who sport a soft yellow-olive getup that’s lovely in its own right, if a little more understated. The males only wear their show-stopping scarlet suits for the breeding season. By the time fall migration rolls around, they’re molting back to something closer to the female’s earth-toned look. It’s like the bird version of changing out of your tux and into sweats for the flight home.
Now, here’s the twist: despite being called a tanager, this bird is now considered a cardinal. Yep, thanks to the magic of modern taxonomy, scarlet tanagers and their Piranga cousins have moved over to the Cardinalidae family. They may lack the seed-smashing conical bill of your backyard cardinal, but in terms of DNA and vocal stylings, they fit right in. So they’re cardinals masquerading as tanagers pretending to be robins. Got it?
You’ll usually hear them before you see them, belting out their raspy little song from the upper reaches of deciduous forests. Oaks seem to be their favourite real estate, and they’re picky—ten hectares or more of good solid woodland, please and thank you. When food is plentiful, they eat insects like a summer buffet: beetles, wasps (minus the stingers—scraped off with panache), cicadas, moths, the works. They also tuck into berries when the bugs run dry, with a preference for good native fare like serviceberries, chokeberries, and mulberries.
They’re forest specialists, which makes them especially vulnerable to the modern scourges of habitat fragmentation, cowbird parasitism, and window collisions. Cowbirds lay their eggs in other birds’ nests, and unlike some savvier species, tanagers haven’t evolved any defenses. So, the smaller and patchier the forest, the worse their odds.
Still, they’re not in crisis—yet. The IUCN lists them as “Least Concern,” which is conservation-speak for “not doing great everywhere, but still hanging on.” Want to help? Keep forests connected, grow native plants, and go easy on the insecticides.
But beyond the ecology and taxonomy and the mouthfuls of Latin, this bird is just a visual gut-punch. One of those “whoa” birds. The kind that sticks with you long after the trip is over, and makes you scroll through your photos again in January, just to remember what real colour looks like.
Let me brighten your Friday.
Sign up for weekly Bird Friday newsletters from my blog. There’s no marketing spam; it’s all birds all the time. We never sell our mailing lists, and you can unsubscribe any time.
Leave a Reply